Key Lime Pie – Bright, Creamy & Full of Florida Flavor

Made with authentic Florida Key lime juice and freshly grated lime zest, this pie strikes the perfect balance between sweet and tart. Baked in our signature golden butter crust, it’s smooth, creamy, and refreshingly bold — the kind of dessert that keeps you coming back for another pie.

Handmade in Oakland, CA, our Key Lime Pie is light, citrusy, and irresistibly flavorful — a true Delightful Foods classic and proudly one of our Top 2 Best Sellers.

📦 Shipping Info

• We ship Tuesdays & Wednesdays only.
• UPS Ground orders ship frozen and arrive in 1–2 days within CA.
• Out-of-state orders are baked, frozen & shipped overnight.
• We only charge what UPS charges us (no markups).
• Please refrigerate on arrival. Pies stay fresh 3–4 days, then freeze if needed.
• We do not ship to P.O. Boxes  

📦 Key Lime Pie Shipping Notice:

Our personal-sized Key Lime Pies ship nationwide. Due to the delicate texture of this pie, large Key Lime Pies are available for local pickup only, as they do not travel well and may be damaged during transport.